Prepared 18 Nov 2026
For Tidemill
Fenwick Mutual
Thursday / 19 Nov 2026, 10:30 / Owner: Founder, sales
Quick facts
- Est. revenue
- £36mCompanies House accounts
- Staff
- ~240LinkedIn / Glassdoor
- Est. growth
- +9%Annual report / launches
Est. figures are Picquet estimates from public sources.
Summary
Fenwick is a regulated insurer that has launched two products this year and has had a finance role open since September. Tidemill, Harbord and Quillon all sell month-end reconciliation software. Tidemill costs £18,240 less than Quillon over three years and goes live six weeks after signing, against 10 to 14 weeks for Harbord and 12 for Quillon.
Lead with 22 January and £180,000: in place for the audit, £18,240 below Quillon over three years.
Who's in the room
Sarah Okonkwo
Head of Finance Operations / Recommender
Sarah leads the 14-person finance team and joined in August. She wants the month-end close to run without another hire.
Daniel Reyes
Finance Operations Manager / Day-to-day owner
Daniel runs month-end reconciliation and would own the rollout. He will test the go-live date and how much time the new process takes from his team.
Fenwick
Fenwick Mutual is a regulated mutual insurer with about 240 staff. It launched pet insurance in March and small-business cover in June, and it publishes its annual report each March.
A new CFO joined in July, and the Head of Finance Operations who leads this team joined in August. The finance team has 14 people and has advertised a reconciliation analyst role since September.
Predictions
- 01
Fenwick wants to avoid another hire.
The role has been open for two months, and a CFO who joined in July will want finance costs that do not rise with each product launch.
- 02
The deadline is the year-end audit.
It is the first audit covering both new products, and the team will want the new process running before it starts.
- 03
The CFO decides and the operations team recommends.
Spend this call on the operational problem, then give the team a summary they can take to the CFO.
Predictions are drawn from the facts above. Fenwick has not stated any of them.
Harbord
Harbord has the largest financial services customer base in this evaluation and a security pack that regulated firms recognise. Fenwick will measure other vendors against it.
Harbord is focusing on larger customers than Fenwick. Since August it has hired its first enterprise sales leader and three implementation staff, extended its security certification to US data centres, and rewritten its homepage for regulated industries. On 29 October it removed public pricing, and on 30 October it removed three mid-market customer stories. Its last three newsletters each led with enterprise features such as multi-entity consolidation.
Customer reviews put it at 10 to 14 weeks this quarter, against 6 to 8 weeks a year ago, and it has lengthened every quarter this year. A signing by 11 December goes live between 19 February and 19 March.
Harbord quotes on request only. It removed its public price list on 29 October and replaced it with a demo request form.
Harbord published a page comparing itself with Tidemill on 2 November. Fenwick can find it, so prepare for its points.
Quillon
Quillon is offering 20% off year one for contracts signed by 31 December. It ran the same offer in each of the last two years and extended it into late January both times.
Quillon's list price for Fenwick's tier is £70,800 a year against Tidemill's £60,000. With the discount, Quillon is £3,360 cheaper in year one and £10,800 more expensive in each of years two and three, which makes the three-year total £198,240 against Tidemill's £180,000. Quillon also starts the subscription at signing and quotes 12 weeks to go live, so in year one Fenwick would pay £1,416 for each week of live use, against £1,304 with Tidemill.
Quillon raised its list price by 7% in March 2025 and 6% in March 2026. If a 6% increase repeats each March, its three-year total is about £211,000.
Objections
“Quillon is cheaper.”
It is cheaper in year one only. The three-year comparison in the Quillon section above gives the figures. If cost certainty is what matters to Fenwick, a fixed three-year price answers it directly.
Quillon's discount applies to year one only. Over three years we come out at £180,000 against their £198,240, and we can put that in a fixed three-year price if it helps your planning.
“Harbord is the safe choice.”
Agree that Harbord is well funded and well known. Fenwick's main risk is a rollout that finishes after the audit, and the dates show that risk with Harbord. A signing by 11 December goes live between 19 February and 19 March, which is after most of the audit period. Harbord's implementation team was hired in September, and it has no published enterprise go-live. Harbord removed its mid-market customer stories on 30 October, so no customer of Fenwick's size is shown on its site.
Whichever way you go, it's worth asking each vendor for a go-live date in writing, the name of the implementation lead, and two customers of your size from the last six months. We can give you all three today.
“We can wait until after year-end.”
A signing by 11 December gives a six week go-live on 22 January, so the new process is in place for most of the audit period. A signing in February goes live in late March, after the annual report is published, and the audit runs on the current process. Waiting also keeps the analyst role open and the team covering the gap for another quarter.
“Our team does not have time to implement.”
Tidemill's implementation takes six weeks, half the 12 that Quillon quotes and roughly half of Harbord's 10 to 14. The team spends fewer weeks on implementation and begins using the product sooner. Introduce the named implementation contact on this call so Fenwick knows who it would work with.